What are Self Assessment Centers?
HAW navigators - sounds a bit like student guides and in principle it is the same: The Hamburg University of Applied Sciences (HAW) wants to give their graduates a taste of their studies with their self-assessment system and thus decide for or against them Faculty of study easier.
Prospective students, like a virtual student advisory service, get a lot of information and quickly notice whether a subject fits them or not. However, participation in most subjects is not voluntary: everyone who wants to apply for a place at HAW should first test their "fit" for the program.
How helpful are self-assessments?
In contrast to assessment centers, which are known from application procedures, one is not observed and assessed by an assessor during the online self-assessment, but assesses himself and tests his suitability for a degree program. Internet-based exercises will be used to check different personality traits according to fitness-diagnostic criteria. The test results are only intended for one person. Self-assessment procedures are used not only at universities, but also by companies specifically for the information of applicants.
"If I am with mine application had not been specifically pointed out at the university, I would not have taken the self-assessment, "
is the twenty-three-year-old Benjamin Pridat from Hamburg, who is now studying mechanical engineering at the HAW in the third semester. Benjamin, who had chosen the course of study in a targeted way, felt strongly supported by the HAW navigators in his study decision. In retrospect, therefore, is glad to have gone through the virtual study advice:
"The program has prepared me very well for everything that was required of me later in my studies. In the test assignments, exactly the focal points were queried that will be of importance later in the course of studies. And I immediately noticed where I still had knowledge gaps - for example in computer science. "
What distinguishes self-assessments from suitability tests?
Exactly this orientation is the goal of the HAW navigators, which were developed by the Hamburg CYQUEST GmbH especially for the HAW: In different modules they show with texts, pictures and videos, which contents and requirements the future students expects. The perspectives on the job market are also important: in short films, HAW graduates will inform you about your professional life. You also learn what it means to study. It shows, for example, that you have to organize your own timetable and how to study in a big city like Hamburg - because such factors will decide later on the success of the study, as Joachim Diercks, managing director of CYQUEST explains:
"In Hamburg, it can quickly come to long driving times between the study sites. Students who find this too much quick to realize through self-assessment that they should study better in a small town. It's a shame if someone has to drop out of university because of such conditions. "
In addition, the students in Spe also have to solve a number of tasks and test their skills. However, what is inquired is not the material that is dealt with in the study, but the knowledge that should be available from the school. However, the results of these tests are only given to prospective students themselves: they receive feedback on how good they were and an assessment of their level of expected success. Based on this result, they can decide for themselves whether the results seem good enough for them to start their studies. A kind of voluntary self-control, then: Some, like Benjamin, thereby confirmed in their choice of study. Others notice that you have completely misconstrued a course of study: for example, you find that studying psychology also includes a large portion of mathematics and statistics. Or they realize that they lack important fundamentals, which may make it difficult to successfully complete their studies.
Example 1: Technical understanding of the Department of Mechanical Engineering
When designing machine parts spatial imagination is required. Of course, the developer also needs a good understanding of the functional relationships in his design. The abilities discussed here are generally not trained at school. However, the applicants should check whether they can get the job done (the complete task and the solution can be found in the HAW Navigator of the Department of Mechanical Engineering):
When the gear 1 is turned clockwise, in which direction does the gear 6 move? Please mark the variant that you think is correct and then click on Next.
Example 2: Business Case of the Department of Economics
Applicants for the Degree Programs in Foreign Economics / International Management (AIM), Logistics / Technical Business Management or Marketing / Technical Business Administration should, inter alia, go through an interactive case study, familiarizing themselves with the day-to-day work of a product manager and dealing with typical business and economic aspects. We show you a part of the task (you can find the complete task and the solution in the HAW-Navigator of the Department of Economics):
"They are product managers at BEANZ AG and responsible for the successful coffee brand" Jungle-High ", a high-quality coffee from the best Colombian highlands, which is mainly bought by young and trend-conscious target groups. As a product manager, you are the key person responsible for all aspects of the Jungle-High brand. This means that your strategic decisions influence, for example, the costs of raw materials, transport or production as well as the packaging design or the selling price. They buy the raw coffee directly from the producer in Colombia, have it brought by ship to Germany, roast in the company-owned roasting house and then distribute it through various supermarket chains.
In the future end product, namely the one-pound pack of "Jungle-High", which is on the supermarket shelf, there are various costs.
Together with your colleagues from the Controlling you have these different cost types once listed and broken down to a "one-pound pack" calculated.
- Coffee: 1,25 Euro
- Packing / transport (final product), Green point: 0,20 Euro
- Marketing costs: 0,40 Euro
- Production costs (roasting, refining): 0,40 Euro
- Transport costs (raw material): 0,30 Euro
- Raw material costs: 1,20 Euro
What is your total cost per one-pound pack?
Feel free to give a recommendation from the gut feeling, at what price "Jungle High" should be sold to the end user. Of course, you have to keep in mind that not only do you want to earn something on every package sold (ie you want to make a so-called contribution margin), but that trade needs a margin, of course.
It is precisely in this mixture of extensive information about studying, background knowledge from professional practice and self-test that CYQUEST's managing director Diercks sees the advantages of his self-assessment system as opposed to mere aptitude tests, with which only knowledge resources are queried.
"At the end, our applicants do not say: 'You are suitable for studying and you are not.' On the contrary, the future students should decide on their own responsibility on the basis of the information and test results whether they feel fit to study at the HAW. The university does not even see the test results, so they will not be considered in the application. "
Self-assessments and aptitude tests at universities at a glance
More and more universities are offering their students virtual study counseling, web-based aptitude tests or self-assessments. Contents and orientations are very different: Some are pure aptitude test, in which only the existing (subject) knowledge is queried and the candidate receives a recommendation at the end. Others help with self-assessment with information to make a decision. Most offers include only the subjects of their own university, some universities have their online offer limited to certain subjects. One exception is the University of Stuttgart-Hohenheim.
University of Applied Sciences Hamburg (HAW):
Duration: 25-60 minutes
Structure: Depending on the subject, different modules on career prospects, study contents and requirements or study organization.
Evaluation: Feedback how good you were and a non-binding assessment of what level is expected in your studies.
Association of North German Universities:
Duration: 90-120 minutes
Structure: The inclination and suitability for the subjects in social, social, humanities, linguistics, law, economics and natural sciences are examined.
Evaluation: In the end, individual feedback on the extent to which your abilities and inclinations match the requirements of the study subjects of the Association of North German Universities.
Duration: 90-120 minutes
Structure: Two modules: Module A contains a performance and aptitude test, module B contains information about the study program and career prospects.
Evaluation: very detailed on more than 20 pages, tailored to the Bochum offer
Rheinisch-Westfälische Technische Hochschule Aachen (RWTH):
Duration: 90 minutes
Structure: Increasing the level of difficulty, first questions about school grades, personal strengths and weaknesses and interests, but also about logic and mathematics.
Evaluation: Based on the Aachen study program
University of Stuttgart-Hohenheim:
Duration: 20 minutes
Structure: 136 Ask questions about school subjects, grades, interests and hobbies, self-assessment in certain areas of "Interested in not interest me at all" on a scale from 1 to 5.
Evaluation: The test refers not only to the own subjects in Hohenheim, but nationwide to about 160 subjects and about 500 professions, so the recommendations are not always accurate.
Johann Wolfgang Goethe University Frankfurt am Main:
Duration: 90 minutes
Structure: Self-assessment for the subject of computer science, which explicitly acts as part of the course guidance and should therefore not serve as the sole basis for decision-making. The system is still in the test phase. To carry out the self-assessment, it is not necessary to stay online. Once individual self-assessment modules have been downloaded, you can disconnect from the Internet and, if necessary, be prompted to activate the Internet connection. The data is then transmitted to the server.
Evaluation: After completing the self-assessment, you will receive detailed feedback that can assist you in your choice of study.
Albert Ludwigs University Freiburg:
Duration: 60 minutes
Structure: Selfassessment only for the subject Anglistik, which on the one hand gives a realistic preview of the contents, workflows and requirements of English studies at the University of Freiburg and on the other hand offers the opportunity to test one's own competencies.
Evaluation: On the basis of an immediate individual feedback, one can estimate whether studying English in Freiburg would be the right choice.
What are the advantages of self-assessments?
As part of the HEAP University E-Assessment project, various self-assessment and aptitude tests in four pilot projects were extensively examined between 2004 and 2006 in Hamburg - with consistently positive results for the self-assessments. Reason enough for HAW Hamburg to introduce the system throughout the university for all subjects and to make it a compulsory part of the study place application process.
This virtual study counseling has several advantages: Firstly, the system taps prospective students throughout Germany - far more than a handful of student advisors could cover on site. First-year students are also supported in choosing the right subject from the very beginning. As a result, you have a lower risk of losing time due to a change of subject or dropout. Applicants are not simply informed, but are encouraged to actively participate.
Against wrong ideas
And the quality of the study is generally better, because the students are better prepared for the requirements and fit the subject, such as Professor Dr. Monika Bessenrodt-Weberpals, Vice President of the Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, explains
"We have always noticed that first-year students had completely wrong ideas about the content of the study and then stopped it more often. This is all the more annoying when they have elaborately declared a place and then realize that it is the wrong thing. One example is our media study programs: Many applicants completely overlook the fact that a lot of technical content is taught here too. On the other hand, those who know what to expect will be more successful from the start. "
HAW has so far introduced self-assessments for the following programs:
- Care and management,
- Social work,
- Foreign Trade / International Management (AIM),
- Logistics / Technical Management Economics,
- Publicmanagement - Logistics / Technical Management,
- Marketing / Technical Management Economics,
- Public Management Mechanical Engineering and Production,
- Hamburg industrial engineering.
Navigators for the degree programs Education, Ecotrophology, Health Sciences, Environmental Technology, Process Engineering, Biotechnology, Hazard Control, Rescue Engineering, Medical Technology, Media Technology and Media Systems are also currently being developed at HAW. At the end of the year, all degree programs at the HAW will be equipped with the Navigator system.
Does self-assessment make students more successful?
It remains to be seen whether self-assessment before graduation will actually lead to a more successful course of study: The first students who have gone through the application process with integrated self-assessments have just completed their first semester - still too early to say anything about the success of the study hold true. After all, the multi-payer of the prospective students, who could be virtually advised, the HAW navigators at the end of the procedure as a good to very good study preparation.
At other universities one is already one step further: For the project Megadigitale at the Johann Wolfgang Goethe University Frankfurt / Main the first evaluation results are already available at least for the subject computer science. Here, the results of 76 Self-Assessments were compared with the results of the first exams using a pseudonym. The evaluation confirmed that there is a correlation between good test and test results.
The limits of self-assessments
As sensible and practical as self-assessments in study orientation are, of course, such systems also have limitations. Example HAW: Since it is only important for the university that an applicant has completed the virtual study orientation at least once and that one is not judged on his performance, it can also happen that an applicant simply clicks through the navigator without using the content. just to tick off the participation. But he is especially bad for himself.
In the view of the German Association for Educational and Vocational Guidance (dvb) eV, it is problematic to rely solely on the results of such online procedures in the self-assessment: even if these are what you can usually expect from self-assessments at universities , have been prepared according to strictly scientific methods and have been adequately tested in advance: the contents, requirements and results presented do not always correspond to reality. Often only partial areas of one's own abilities are tested, so test results are not always accurate.
Do not consider self-assessments
And self-assessments usually do not take into account that prospective students can still develop over time. For this reason, you should definitely discuss the recommendations of virtual study counseling with teachers or student advisors.
In addition, prospective students should make it clear that a university pursued with such a test, of course, always own interests: For example, the HAW wants to use their navigators specifically study subjects with very low numbers of applicants particularly attractive, for example, by exciting job opportunities. At the same time, in subjects with a large number of interested applicants, potential students should be made aware of possible difficulties during their studies - the deterrent effect is quite deliberate. This can be positive if it clears up misconceptions about a field of study, but it also shows that the quality of a self-assessment always depends on the intentions of its creators. This makes this virtual orientation method not less recommendable, but it should never be considered completely uncritical.
haw-navigator.net - here you will find an overview of all navigators at the University of Applied Sciences. To test one of the navigators, you can use the eMail-Address email@example.com and password "guest" and find all the information, tasks and solutions as well as your personal recommendation.
Examples of self-assessment procedures in job search are the applications "CyPRESS", which provides insights into the Hamburg media group Gruner + Jahr or the career orientation game "Tr.AX", which informs about the great variety of training occupations at Deutsche Bahn.
More knowledge - PDF download, eCourses or personal advice
Offline download: Download this text as PDF - Read usage rights, Because we do not automatically submit the title of this text for privacy reasons: When buying in "interests" the title register if support is needed. After buying text exclusively Download at this URL (please save).
Your eCourse on Demand: Choose your personal eCourse on this or another desired topic, As a PDF download. Up to 30 lessons with each 4 learning task + final lesson. Please enter the title under "interests". Alternatively, we are happy to put together your course for you or offer you a personal regular eMailCourse including supervision and certificate - all further information!
Consultant packages: You want to increase your reach or address applicants as an employer? For these and other topics we offer special Consultant packages (overview) - For example, a personal phone call (price is per hour).