Go to Article

Better work, information as desired: We give you the information you really need and are committed to a better and more ecological working environment. When Book Publisher Best of HR – Berufebilder.de® with Unique Book Concept and eCourses we offer over 20 years of experience in Corporate Publishing - with Clients like Samsung, Otto, Governmental Institutions. Publisher Simone Janson also heads the Institute Berufebilder Yourweb, which awards scholarships and belongs to one of the top 10 female German bloggers, referenced in ARD, FAZ, ZEIT, WELT, Wikipedia .

Disclosure & Image Rights: Artwork created as part of a free collaboration with Shutterstock. 

Here writes for you:

Tanja rememberTanja Merkens is an appraiser at Arbeitszeugnis-valu.de Tanja Merkens completed her Masters in Human Resource Management at the University of Hamburg and has been an appraiser for job references at Arbeitszeugnis-bewerten.de (a product of PMSG Personalmarkt Services GmbH) since 2006. In addition, she is an expert on topics related to recruiting and advises employees on a successful application process. As the portal manager for the salary comparison gehalt.de, she is also responsible for the content of the website.

5 cons of more responsibility, career and salary: dead end carriage

Promotion and career make more money? We have analyzed the salary data of selected occupational groups for you, which make it clear from an employee's and personnel perspective: more responsibility does not always have to be an advantage.

Career_no_thank you

More work satisfaction due to higher salary?

Work satisfaction and motivation are usually associated with the level of salary and the value assessment experienced in everyday life by supervisors and colleagues. The amount of the salary is usually understood as a recognition of the performance and should increase continuously through professional experience, job changes as well as concrete successes over the years.

As far as idealism is concerned, there are also good reasons to question this expectation. Both from the perspective of the workforce and the employee's perspective, there can be comprehensible reasons to think twice about a promotion. Thus, there are some professional groups whose career structure offers little salary in the lower and middle range, and are usually stalled after a career gap.

Selected professional examples

The following table presents the salary data of selected occupational groups, which show a dilemma in the employment biography, both from the perspective of the employees and the staff: the tension between transport, increase in responsibility and salary.

In the selected professions, the first level was chosen with professional and / or disciplinary personnel responsibilities to illuminate the real salary advantage. The call centers, care and education as well as gastronomy provide the basis for further consideration. The salary data are from the past 12 months and were provided by the Compensation Partner compensation committee:

Tip: Text as PDF (please read the instructions!) or to this text complete eCourse or series Download. Actions or news via Newsletter!

Job Title: Median annual salary: monthly. Plus:
Team Leader Call Center 27.768€ 2.314€ 504€
call center agent 21.720€ 1.810€
deputy head 36.168€ 3.014€ 514€
Educator daycare 30.000€ 2.500€
Deputy Head of Department 38.634€ 3.219€ 411€
Nurse / nurses 33.701€ 2.808€
Laundry line 30.791€ 2.565€ 639€
Housekeeper / in 23.117€ 1.926€
restaurant manager 26.400€ 2.200€ 422€
Restaurant / -frau 21.337€ 1.778€

The employee perspective

A team leader position is to be filled and the boss has already someone in the visor, which would fit well. What at first sounds very flattering to the chosen one, however, can, on closer examination, bring more disadvantages than advantages. In all five occupational groups, the next highest level of management assumes overall responsibility for day-to-day business and must help out or step in in the event of a staff shortage.

All professions have in common that high quality standards in the form of health regulations or certifications must be observed and these are sometimes very costly documented. In the case of misconduct or a breach by employees, the lower management level is initially held responsible.

5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career and salary

  1. What many do not consider: More responsibility often means more overtime. Accountability, fluctuation, achievement of the management's goals, which must be met, and many other requirements can be enumerated when the increase in responsibility is considered in its entirety. This increases the stress factor, on the other hand, it also means more work. Often, a willingness to work overtime is assumed, which can be regarded as compensated by the salary levy.
  2. Reject a promotion and live well with it? From an employee perspective, this can Sense because sometimes a new job title is associated with a high level of commitment and emotional investment, without the relevant salary leveling off.
  3. Financially particularly negative, it can be for the restaurant manager, according to the Compensation partner only a plus of monthly gross 422 € and usually no more tip gets. This example is, however, also a special one since this position is the only one that often provides a switch for the change to self-employment. This financially unsatisfactory situation is often accepted because it serves a further career step.
  4. A second career jump with a significant salary increase is not really provided for in many other examples, so can the curious case occur that a teacher with many years of professional experience has a better merit than a social worker in a managerial capacity. Their salary is determined not only by more responsibility, but also by the number of children / facility area to be supervised.
  5. Sometimes the refusal of a promotion or the conscious decision not to send an internal application can serve the career much more. The liberalized training market offers a large number of opportunities to qualify part-time, in order to then raise the professional experience from day-to-day business to a new (salary) level.

From superiors perspective

The motives for a promoted promotion can be quite different, even if the main reason is clear: the shop should run and the employee relieve the boss. Nevertheless, a responsible handling of a promotion should take place.

A big risk is to "burn" on one post. It is not uncommon for potential candidates to draw attention to themselves who show a high level of work performance over a long period of time. A desirable property in itself - however, if there is a lack of concrete knowledge for the fulfillment of the tasks, the overwork is preprogrammed.

Employees gently build up instead of burning?

Solid familiarization and support should be a matter of course, but the boss can give the candidate more preference in a more relaxed manner - even if he is not the top performer of the team. Because someone who “rolls over” permanently will find it difficult to survive the long dry spell at a level of responsibility.

On the other hand, it would be best to build up a promising employee with care. A sophisticated talent management does not necessarily exist. Recognition and qualification can go hand in hand, if a superior thinks about Jobenrichment, offers participation in project work or even grants exemptions for further education.

The worry that money invested in the employee migrates with this is not to be swept aside, but permanently no alternative, if job satisfaction, performance and expectations of a reasonable salary development to be balanced.

Books on the topic

4 responses to "5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career and salary: dead end promotion"

  1. Luis Antonio says:

    RT @Berufebilder: 5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career & salary: dead end promotion - - Recommended contribution 4luFzLitBA

  2. Competencepartner says:

    5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career & salary: dead end promotion of Tanja Merkens ... - Recommended contribution Ooy3FKYkO9 #Profession #Development

  3. REGIS GMBH says:

    5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career & salary: dead end Promotion of Tanja… via BERUFEBILDER - Recommended contribution kBTRDCE5kd

  4. Thomas Eggert says:

    5 disadvantages of more responsibility, career & salary: dead end Promotion of Tanja… via BERUFEBILDER - Recommended contribution IH0AOKGsMy

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * .

Ja, I would like to be informed about the latest promotions and offers via Newsletter be informed.

I hereby accept the Debate Rules and the Privacy policy with the possibility to contradict the use of my data at any time.

error: warning The content is protected!