Fuore cares for the time Professor Dr. Gerd Bosbach from the Rhein-Ahr-Campus in Remagen with his book “Lies with Numbers: How We Are Manipulated with Statistics”, in which he takes the statistical lies of our society into focus. The figures circulating in the media such as the 6,5 million shortage of skilled workers by 2025 are coffee grounds reading.
What are professionals?
I had expected a correspondingly polemical discussion at the panel discussion “The fairy tale about the shortage of skilled workers?” on the occasion of the specialist personnel recruitment conference of the future in the past week in Berlin. And then I was pleasantly surprised.
So Bosbach pleaded for, just to differentiate what actually understood by professionals: This is namely a very elastic term whose definition somewhere between doctor and bakery saleswoman commutes and therefore each defines as it fits him in the junk.
Is there a shortage of skilled labor in Germany? It discussed (from left to right) Dr. Karl Brenke from the DIW, Malte Hansen from the Bund der Personalmanager, Antje Rabenalt from Zukunft im Zentrum and Professor Dr. Gerd Bosbach from the Rhein-Ahr-Campus.
Do not trust statistics ...
At all, one should always distinguish between absolute and relative numbers and, in the case of statistics, prefer to find what is meaningful and what is not. And do not rely on the interpretations of others!
Exactly this results in the misunderstanding of a general shortage of skilled workers. However, according to Bosbach, it certainly exists in some less attractive industries and regions. Specialists in wastewater just want to be the least.
What exactly are you looking for?
There would have to, suggested Professor before that Company then specify exactly who or what they are looking for. And then just lure with very good conditions such as permanent contracts or targeted training measures - so far break the training company not exactly because of excessive demand together.
And also be open to, for example, secondary school pupils, who have to be prepared for the job in corresponding further education measures, even in individual care. That was, as Bosbach knew from his own experience with further training measures, very successful.
Especially the small ones are affected
And small companies, which could not support the technological change, would only have a chance to find reasonable candidates at all.
That was the crux that could be agreed in the discussion: That especially smaller and very specialized companies are affected by a shortage of skilled workers - and moderator Antje Rabenalt had at the same time a whole series of examples of dedicated entrepreneurs ready, despite high personal Can not afford suitable employees - and who simply do not have the money to hire someone to do the HR work.
Why are engineers rejected?
But she also had the counterexample of an engineer who had been doing all sorts of jobs for 15 for years, just not working in his job - and who had, over time, gotten a variety of cancellations:
Overqualified, under-qualified, too old, too little professional experience. He could not be present himself: he had just finally found a job.
Companies are too spoiled
The real provocateur this evening was Dr. Karl Brenke from DIW, who had caused a stir last year with his study of the shortage of skilled workers. And Brenke saw the dilemma of smaller companies, especially in the insufficient human resources work or in human weaknesses of the snoring owners - a statement that caused fierce criticism in the audience.
Moreover, over the last 20 years, companies have been simply spoiled by the labor market, which allowed them to find only people who matched 150%. Maybe, according to Brenke, companies would just have to get used to the fact that it only fits 90 or 80 percent and then they just have to qualify.
Personnel need to become more flexible!
Personnel would have to be more flexible. In general, rigid thinking is the problem in Germany: in other countries, companies react much more flexibly to a situation despite higher levels of employment. Therefore it is no wonder that many skilled workers migrated to Scandinavia or to Switzerland.
In addition, there are already many foreign specialists in Germany, but their degrees are not recognized and therefore work in unskilled jobs. Here, too, companies should become more open-minded.
Temporary work instead of further education
Another problem for Brenke: This is also under highly qualified spreading temporary work. Companies that want to get cheap labor in this way therefore do not give any further training.
Malte Hansen of the Personnel Managers (BPM) had little to compare. From the point of view of his association, he has already noted a shortage in some regions and professions. But he really could not refute the presented arguments. The picture was differentiated.
The company's view
He dismissed the allegation that the companies were too comfortable: companies would never be used to finding 150% suitable employees - at most 110%. Hansen also spoke out against open-ended contracts: it had to be possible for the company to get to know its employees for two years.
And Hansen also expressed himself against the opening up of companies to unqualified forces - it could not be the goal to make the training even worse. Companies, he reiterated, also sought engineers. Nevertheless, nobody from the Association of German Engineers wanted to take part in the discussion.
Money or time
After all, it was also clear to Hansen that companies had to move. Ultimately, the companies had two options: On the one hand, to spend a lot of money in order to get the right skilled workers. There would also be problems such as regionality and mobility. “The specific challenges depend on the company, location and person.”
Or invest in the respective employees, but pay less. One way that he could go to small companies, because the big ones, Hansen said, were not necessarily the best work.
Do you only hit the magic word
The all-encompassing question of whether the shortage of skilled workers was a fairy tale or not could only be answered with a brave yes and no. Ultimately, it is a matter of a differentiated view of the respective industry, region, situation and location. If magic words and reality meet, the message is "look closely, it all depends."
Text as PDF, book or eCourse on the topic or personal advice
Offline download: Download this text as PDF - Read usage rights, Because we do not automatically submit the title of this text for privacy reasons: When buying in "interests" the title register if support is needed. After buying text exclusively Download at this URL (please save). Or for a little more directly an entire book or eCourse with this text buy, read on.
Your eCourse on Demand: Choose your personal eCourse on this or another desired topic, As a PDF download. Up to 30 lessons with each 4 learning task + final lesson. Please enter the title under "interests". Alternatively, we are happy to put together your course for you or offer you a personal regular eMailCourse including supervision and certificate - all further information!
Consultant packages: You want to increase your reach or address applicants as an employer? For these and other topics we offer special Consultant packages (overview) - For example, a personal phone call (price is per hour).