The end of a networker
It takes a long time to set up and describe such networks: For example, Zumwinkel sat on the Supervisory Board of Lufthansa AG, but also on the Supervisory Board of Arcandor / Karstadt.
The Supervisory Board of Deutsche Telekom was in front of Zumwinkel; He also supervised Postbank and the investment bank Morgan Stanley. Until the end of 2003, Zumwinkel was on the supervisory board of Allianz, one of the germ cells of the old Germany AG, and until August 2003 member of the supervisory board of Tchibo Holding AG. In addition, he sat on the board of the Federal Association of German Employers' Associations and was president of the Research Institute for the Future of Work. This network was the capital of the old brand Zumwinkel. And suddenly it was used up.
The shock that this triggered in the German world of managers, you can not imagine big enough - especially since he triggered many people who could have evaded their taxes in a similar way, the pressing questions about a self-report. Today, however, we know for sure that at the time at least the then Bayern manager Uli Hoeneß has not brought to rethink.
So too often is measured with two levels. This also applies to the former postalChef: In his own role as chairman of the supervisory board of Telekom, however, Zumwinkel had cracked down when he put in November 2006 the then CEO Ricke before the door. At that time his allegations to Ricke were that the investments of the past had not counted and promises had not been fulfilled.
With two dimensions
At the time, Zumwinkel formulated this criticism without conveying a feeling of pity. Even without the discussion about possible tax evasion, the Post-Supervisory Board Zumwinkel would have been able to measure itself against the criteria that applied to Telekom and Ricke. Zumwinkel's investments in America have not been expected either - on the contrary, there was a retreat ahead of his departure, which ended an adventure that cost many billions of euros.
His promises with regard to the conquest of the American market, he has thus also not redeemed. Zumwinkel wanted to go more praiseworthy than Ricke. But all senior politicians he knew were on dark Thursday morning in Cologne-Marienburg and the day after no help. The net stopped.
Nevertheless, the top decision maker for 2008 was the only one to receive a bonus. Such developments have helped to make the reputation of managers so bad. First, the regret is missing in case of mistakes, then there are high severance pay. In the case of Zumwinkel, there were pension entitlements totaling 20 millions of euros, which he was able to pay off, as well as the bonus payments - more than 480.000 euros for two months.
From Zumwinkel to Hoeneß
The former manager of FC Bayern Munich, Uli Hoeneß, helped his own, dense network of relationships years later. On the contrary, he has to pay with imprisonment of three years and six months for his tax evasion (from which he can spend most of his time since the beginning of 2015 as a freelancer with a regular job at his football club). Because the district court of Munich owed the president of FC Bayern Munich in spring 2014 in one of the most spectacular tax proceedings in Germany in seven cases guilty.
The court classified the self-report as incomplete, so as not punitive liberating: The presiding judge said that the self-report, the Hoeness had made well a year earlier, was "not only failed, but clearly insufficient." On that basis, the tax office could not even make an estimate. Hoeneß himself blamed himself for that. His accountant did not just forget about "some note".
Make pure table in time
The court also did not deny Hoeneß the claim that its bank should have done all business on its own. The Economic Criminal Court estimated the tax damage at 28,5 million euros. For the punishment it does not matter whether further evaluations of the bank documents from Switzerland should yield even higher amounts.
In addition, the court also left open whether the self-report had come too late. Although the judges believed that Hoeneß himself was out of fear of exposing his account by the magazine "Stern": "They were driven out of fear of discovery." Hoeneß, however, had years before, to clear the table , In fact, years were at this time finally the case Zumwinkel back.
More knowledge - PDF download, eCourses or personal advice
Offline download: Download this text as PDF - Read usage rights, Because we do not automatically submit the title of this text for privacy reasons: When buying in "interests" the title register if support is needed. After buying text exclusively Download at this URL (please save).
Your eCourse on Demand: Choose your personal eCourse on this or another desired topic, As a PDF download. Up to 30 lessons with each 4 learning task + final lesson. Please enter the title under "interests". Alternatively, we are happy to put together your course for you or offer you a personal regular eMailCourse including supervision and certificate - all further information!
Consultant packages: You want to increase your reach or address applicants as an employer? For these and other topics we offer special Consultant packages (overview) - For example, a personal phone call (price is per hour).